October 15, 2012

Fact checking the first presidential debate

John Santos 
News Editor 

The polls are looking better for Republican candidate Mitt Romney after the October 3 presidential debate. According to a CBS poll, 46% of Americans thought Romney won the debate while only 22% thought Obama won.

The debate, which had an official topic of domestic policy, was heavily focused on the economy and job creation. One of the biggest points of the night was when Obama said Romney’s plan “calls for a $5 trillion tax cut,” which Romney steadily denied. Obama failed to mention that this figure was cumulative over a ten year period. According to the Tax Policy Center, Romney’s tax cuts would lower federal tax liability by $480 billion in 2015.
Later in the debate, Romney accused Obama of doubling the deficit. This is not true, as the deficit was at $1.2 trillion when Obama came into office and deficits have remained at or above that level since then (FactCheck.org). However, Romney was correct in saying Obama has failed to keep his promise to cut the deficit in half.

On the topic of healthcare, Obama claimed that because of his Affordable Care Act, health care premiums have gone up “slower than any time in the last 50 years.” This is true about health care spending in general, but not specifically premiums (FactCheck.org). Romney stated that the Congressional Budget Office has estimated that “20 million people will lose their insurance” due to the Affordable Care Act. The CBO stated that this may happen, but only in the worst case scenario and it is not a realistic outcome.

Another topic of discussion after the debate was the lack of control moderator Jim Lehrer had over the candidates. Both candidates went over their time limits on many questions, simply blowing over moderator Lehrer when he tried to cut them off at the time limit.

The vice presidential debate will take place at Centre College in Danville, Kentucky on Thursday, October 11. The next presidential debate will take place at Hofstra University in Hempstead, New York on Tuesday, October 16.