April 30, 2015

Indonesia executes foreigners despite international protest

Kenison Garratt
Staff Writer

Indonesia has formally notified 10 prisoners convicted of drug trafficking that their executions will be carried out as soon as possible. On Saturday, the nine foreigners and one Indonesian man were told their executions by firing squad were to be carried out in Besi prison on Nusakambangan Island. Indonesia has incredibly strict drug laws and often executes smugglers; more than 130 people are on death row, mostly for drug crimes. One third of these convicts are foreigners.

When Indonesian President Joko Widodo took office last October, he declared Indonesia to be facing a drug crisis. Indonesia has some of the toughest drug laws in the world. But Jakarta believes their country’s drug problem justifies their harsh punishments; 33 Indonesians die every day as a result of drugs.


The execution has caused an international outcry and has angered Indonesia’s largest aid donors, including Australia and the European Union. In January, six convicted drug smugglers were executed at the same prison, two were from the Netherlands and Brazil. These two nations recalled their ambassadors in protest, and Australia may be following suit after the upcoming executions. United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon advised Widodo to “urgently consider declaring a moratorium on capital punishment in Indonesia, with a view toward abolition.”

France and the Philippines, who both oppose the death penalty, are also upset. French President Francois Hollande has mentioned the diplomatic and economic consequences of executing their compatriot. Philippine’s President Benigno Aquino III planned to again appeal the case of Filipino convict Mary Jane Veloso to Widodo. Veloso wrote Aquino from the Indonesian prison she resided in, claiming she was tricked into carrying illegal drugs as she traveled in the hopes of gaining a job as a house helper, “Please save my life, I have two children who need the love of their mother. We're poor and I wanted to change our life but I could never commit the crime they have accused me of.”

A French citizen on the list to be executed won a two week reprieve by the State Administrative Court in Jakarta, which will hear his challenge to a clemency rejection by Widodo. But, for the rest of the convicts, Indonesia is proceeding with the execution despite international protest and pleads for clemency. Tony Spontana, spokesman for the Indonesian attorney general’s office says, “We are confirmed for the nine people to go to execution.”

Advocates for the convicts argue the Indonesian courts that sentenced the convicts were corrupt. One Nigerian didn’t have a lawyer when he tried to appeal to his death sentence. The Brazilian convict, Rodrigo Gularte, has had schizophrenia and bipolar disorder since he was a teenager. His lawyers argue these conditions should have disqualified him from criminal prosecution under Indonesian law. The Indonesian wife of another convicted Nigerian claims the judges at her husband’s trial offered a lighter sentence in exchange for a bribe, lawyers for the two Australian convicts declare the same. The two Australian men, members of the Bali Nine, admit their guilt and say they have reformed since the 2005 incident where they attempted to smuggle 18 pounds of heroin from Indonesia to Australia. But, one of the judges involved in the case denied allegations surrounding bribes, “I can assure you there was none. We protected ourselves from everybody. It was purely our decision.”

Australian Foreign Minister Julie Bishop urged Indonesia to halt the execution of its two nationals until a corruption investigation was complete. However, ambulances arrived Tuesday with coffins for the convicts, and relatives were given five hours for a final visit. On Monday, an Australian prisoner, Andrew Chan, married his Indonesian fiancĂ©e in a small wedding ceremony at the prison. Chan’s brother described their emotional farewell, “I saw today something that no other family should ever have to go through. To walk out of there and say goodbye for the last time, it is torture. No family should go through that.”

Europe’s 47 nation human rights organization, the Council of Europe, issued a statement Tuesday telling Indonesia to not go through with the execution. Council of Europe’s Secretary General Thorbjorn Jagland said, “The death penalty is a terrible injustice which can never be put right.” But, Indonesia continues to ignore appeals by foreign leaders to spare their lives, believing court rulings could not be amended and foreigners lack a legal standing for a judicial review. A sister of one death row inmate said, “There were so many things to talk about. We did talk about the death penalty and he knows this is just a waste... I ask the president [of Indonesia] to please show mercy, please don't let my mum and my sister have to bury my brother.”


Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott recalled their ambassador after the executions took place Wednesday morning. He believes the execution of the two Australian men, Chan and Myuran Sukumaran, was unnecessary because the two had been “fully rehabilitated” during 10 years in prison. These two men were among eight drug smugglers executed by the firing squad of 12, Veloso was spared at the last moment, her mother commented, “We are so happy, so happy. I thought I had lost my daughter already but God is so good. Thank you to everyone who helped us.” But, there was still great guilt surrounding the situation. One of the Australian men’s Indonesian lawyer tweeted his apologies, “I failed. I lost. I’m sorry.”